A 29-year-old account manager says their boss offered a $22,000 raise on one condition: no promotion for at least two more years. The Reddit post, shared Nov. 11 in the r/careerguidance community, was reported by the Daily Dot on Nov. 13, when it had 454 comments.
The poster says they have been an account manager for four years and that one of the company’s biggest clients wants to deal only with them, with a threat to reconsider its contract if they move to another position. They had spent the past year working toward a senior management role and expected to be considered for the next opening. Then their boss pulled them aside and made the offer: more pay for the same job, “just more money to keep this client happy,” as the poster put it, with no management duties and no change in title. The post ends with a question, whether to take the money or push for the promotion, and a worry about career progression at 29.
The Daily Dot could not verify the post, which is one person’s account.
What are commenters telling them?
The Daily Dot quoted three of the 454 comments. One advised taking the raise and thanking the boss. A reply to that comment said to get the deal in writing, with a retention bonus and severance if the company lets the poster go within the two years, because the company is asking for a commitment and that “should come with additional compensation.” A third commenter said two years would not necessarily derail a career and asked whether $22,000 would put the poster above what a promotion would pay, adding that being a manager is not always what it is cracked up to be.
How big is $22,000? Our math
The poster does not give a salary, so the table shows what the offer is worth against four example salaries. The raise would pay out every year, so over the two years it is $44,000 before tax.
| Example salary | $22,000 as a raise | Over two years, pre-tax |
|---|---|---|
| $60,000 | 36.7% | $44,000 |
| $80,000 | 27.5% | $44,000 |
| $100,000 | 22.0% | $44,000 |
| $120,000 | 18.3% | $44,000 |
A promotion only beats the offer on money if the raise that comes with it, multiplied by the years it would start earlier, is bigger than $44,000. A management job with a $15,000 raise, for example, would be worth $30,000 over the same two years, $14,000 less. The post does not say what the management role pays, or whether the boss would put the two-year deal in a contract, which is what the second commenter’s advice depends on.