Daniel Roebuck says it “hurts my heart” that he has to deal with the story of his firing from Home Alone every Christmas, after director Chris Columbus called the actor he fired “just awful.” Roebuck, who has identified himself as that actor, told Page Six, according to LADbible, that he holds no grudge.
Columbus made the remark on the Wildmen podcast, hosted by his son Brendan and Dylan Sprouse, in an episode released on Tuesday, Nov. 17. He said Daniel Stern was the first choice to play Marv, but that the studio would not pay for Stern, so the production tried another actor opposite Joe Pesci.
“We tried this other guy,” Columbus said. “And we did a screen test and they were horrible. I mean, Pesci was great.” He called the actor “just awful” and said it is the only time he has had to fire anyone. He did not name him.
Roebuck says he never filmed a screen test with Pesci
Roebuck, 63, said he has “the utmost respect” for Columbus, and that after he was fired and told he would be in Columbus’s next movie, “I waited by the phone, man.” He said he did not hold a grudge over the firing itself.
What he disputes is the screen test. According to Roebuck, he “never, ever, ever” filmed with Pesci. He said they spent one day together and the cameras were not rolling.
Roebuck also pointed to the film’s money. “How horrible could I have been if I was the second choice for a $35 million movie?” he asked. Reference sources put the budget lower. The San Francisco Chronicle reported that Home Alone cost $18 million to make. The American Film Institute catalog cites a contemporary report putting the budget at $18.2 million. Roebuck did not say where the $35 million figure came from.
| Detail | Columbus | Roebuck |
|---|---|---|
| Screen test with Pesci | Says one was filmed and went badly | Says none was filmed |
| Time with Pesci | Not stated | One day, cameras off |
| The firing | Only person he has fired | No grudge, but it hurts |
| Budget | Not stated | $35 million, his figure |

A production summary on Wikipedia adds detail on the casting but does not settle the disputed screen test. It says Stern dropped out when he was told the schedule had grown from six weeks to eight and he would not be paid more for it. It says Roebuck was hired to replace him, and that after two days of rehearsal Columbus felt he lacked chemistry with Pesci and brought Stern back.
That account does not mention a filmed screen test, and it gives Roebuck’s own later view, that the firing was “a little blip of unimportance.”
In other news, Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer took $6.7 million on its opening day, as another Christmas release looks for an audience.