A FanDuel legal executive told jurors in the Clase and Ortiz trial on Monday that accounts registered to men linked to Emmanuel Clase bet on the first pitch of an inning in two Luis Ortiz starts in June 2025, ESPN reported. Both Cleveland Guardians pitchers have pleaded not guilty to conspiracy charges in Brooklyn federal court.
Joshua Mehta, FanDuel’s director of legal and regulatory affairs, testified that bets placed through an account registered to Enoc Pena, whom government witnesses have described as a close associate of Clase’s and whom the defense calls a liar, won about $12,000 on a June 15 pitch against Seattle that Ortiz threw outside the strike zone. Some of the same accounts bet again on Ortiz’s first pitch of the third inning against St. Louis on June 27. BroBible reported that gamblers made more than $19,000 in profit on that pitch, and cited The Athletic for the detail that six bets were placed on it.
Mehta said at least five accounts that bet on the Ortiz pitches were suspended in June 2025, noting that using inside information to bet violates FanDuel’s terms of service. BroBible, citing The Athletic, put it at four accounts that bet on both pitches; the two reports may be counting different sets of accounts. A FanDuel account in Clase’s own name, opened in May 2023, showed only NBA bets, Mehta said.

Other testimony and two readings of the chicken texts
Earlier Monday, cooperating witness Jenner Olivo said he won bets on Clase pitches using Pena’s tips and, BroBible reported, sent three payments totaling $5,500 to a man in the Dominican Republic at Pena’s direction. On cross-examination, he acknowledged he never directly discussed betting with Clase.
On Tuesday, FBI special agent Noah Bilger testified that records showed Pena won $9,890 on Clase’s first pitch to Bobby Witt Jr. on April 12, 2025, RG reported, citing ESPN. In a screenshot prosecutors showed jurors, a message from the next day attributed to Clase reads, “Send some of that to the DR for me,” and says the money was for repairs to a country house, ESPN reported.
Prosecutors say Clase used words like “chicken” and “rooster” as code. In one September 2023 message shown to jurors in BroBible’s translation, he allegedly wrote, “It’s chicken number three. After killing the first two, play number three.” A cooperating bettor, Luis de Aza, testified on Nov. 6 that it meant Clase would rig a pitch after retiring the first two batters of an inning. TSN reported that a similar message sent Sept. 30, 2023 came on a day Clase did not appear in the game.
Clase’s lawyers say he was talking about real cockfighting, which is legal in the Dominican Republic, and presented videos of caged roosters he had shared. In opening statements, they cast Pena as a gambler who used Clase as his mark. Ortiz’s lawyer, Samuel Landes, told jurors only two of his client’s pitches are at issue, both balls. “That’s not a conspiracy. That’s just baseball,” he said.
What the indictment said about those two June games
Mehta’s two games match the dates in the Justice Department’s November 2025 announcement. The indictment alleges bettors agreed to pay Ortiz and Clase $5,000 each for a ball on June 15 and $7,000 each for a ball on June 27, and that Clase withdrew $50,000 in cash before the second game and gave $15,000 to a co-conspirator to bet with. Those are allegations, and the defense disputes them.
The government puts bettors’ winnings on the two Ortiz pitches at no less than $60,000. The two FanDuel figures reported from this week’s testimony add up to roughly $31,000, about half that total. The figures are not like-for-like: the $12,000 covers Pena’s bets, the $19,000 is a reported minimum in profit, and the government’s $60,000 is its estimate of winnings from what it calls fraudulent wagers across sportsbooks. The press release does not break the $60,000 down by sportsbook. If convicted, each pitcher faces up to 20 years on each of the wire fraud conspiracy, honest services wire fraud conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy counts, and up to five years on the sports bribery count. Those are statutory maximums, not likely sentences.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Nov. 9, 2025 | Indictment unsealed; Ortiz arrested in Boston |
| March 6, 2026 | Trial moved from May 4 to Nov. 2 |
| Nov. 2, 2026 | Jury selection begins in Brooklyn |
| Nov. 4 | Opening statements |
| Nov. 5 | Ex-Guardians catcher Bo Naylor testifies for the defense |
| Nov. 6 | Bettor Luis de Aza explains the chicken texts |
| Nov. 16 | FanDuel’s Mehta and bettor Jenner Olivo testify |
| Nov. 17 | FBI agent Noah Bilger testifies |
Naylor testified that none of the disputed Clase pitches he reviewed looked unusual, Courthouse News reported. Prosecutors hope to rest their case by Friday, Nov. 20.
In other news, four NFL officials worked two games in one day after the FAA ground stop forced an officiating scramble.