Viral Stories

New Jersey mom says a restaurant put an automatic 18% gratuity on her party of five’s $300 bill, though the menu said six or more

A Welcome to Elizabeth sign on a street in Elizabeth, New Jersey, with an inset of a tip jar
Stock images, not the restaurant involved. Photo: Timothy Shields, CC BY 3.0. Inset: Tomwsulcer, CC0 / Wikimedia Commons. / Main: File:Welcome to Elizabeth - panoramio.jpg, Timothy Shields, CC BY 3.0. Inset: none yet (intended File:Jar for tips at a restaurant in New Jersey.JPG, Tomwsulcer, CC0; Wikimedia download rate-limited). Inline: File:Restaurant table at Amantaka luxury Resort & Hotel in Luang Prabang Laos.jpg, Basile Morin, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Vanessa Cruz says an Elizabeth, New Jersey, restaurant charged her family of five an 18% gratuity that its menu listed only for parties of six or more.

A New Jersey mom says a restaurant in Elizabeth added an automatic gratuity of 18% to her family’s birthday dinner bill of more than $300, even though its digital menu said the charge applied to parties of six or more. Vanessa Cruz, whose group had five people, described the dispute to Fox News Digital in an interview published on Nov. 18.

When she questioned the charge, Cruz says, the server told her the restaurant also adds 18% to any bill over $200. Cruz says that rule wasn’t on the menu. The family paid the full gratuity after speaking with a manager, whom she described as courteous.

This is Cruz’s account. The restaurant has not been named in the coverage, and no receipt or menu appears in the coverage we reviewed, so neither the charge nor the menu wording has been independently confirmed.

A five-person table, a six-person rule and a $200 line

The dinner was for her mother-in-law’s birthday. Cruz was there with her husband and their two children, ages 6 and 2, according to the Daily Dot, and she told Fox her objection was about choice, not money. “My choice of tipping was taken away from me,” she said.

Cruz first told the story in a TikTok video posted around mid-October under the handle @vannibk. The Daily Dot reported on Oct. 30 that the clip had 186,100 views and 3,052 comments at the time.

In the video, as the Daily Dot described it, she says she read the fine print on the restaurant’s digital menu, saw the six-or-more rule, counted five and thought no more of it. She says the food and drinks took a while to arrive, and that the server greeted them in a dry but not rude way and was not particularly attentive. The manager at first repeated the server’s explanation, then agreed with her and suggested she call the restaurant to leave feedback, according to that account.

Cruz, a real estate agent who considers herself part of the service industry, told Fox she wasn’t trying to skip the tip and that automatic gratuities can be fair for large groups when they are clearly disclosed. She praised the food. “When did it become my problem?” she asked about wages that she says should be built into prices.

A set restaurant table with a white tablecloth and glasses
A restaurant table setting, shown for illustration only; not the restaurant in this story. Photo: Basile Morin, CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Here is what the numbers look like on a $300 check. The figures are illustrations, because Cruz has not shared her exact bill.

On a $300 checkAmount
18% automatic gratuity$54.00
15% tip$45.00
20% tip$60.00
18% at the server’s $200 line$36.00
NJ sales tax at 6.625%$19.88
Calculated from the figures Cruz gave and the state sales tax rate. Her exact bill was not published.

An 18% charge on $300 comes to $54, which sits between what a 15% and a 20% tip would have been. At the $200 line the server described, the automatic charge would start at $36.

How New Jersey treats a gratuity on the bill

New Jersey’s Division of Taxation sets out when a restaurant’s gratuity line escapes sales tax in its restaurant tax bulletin. The bulletin says a gratuity charge is not subject to sales tax when it is separately stated on the bill, specifically labeled as a gratuity or tip, and all of the money management receives is paid to employees.

A charge that does not meet those conditions is not covered by that rule, so it can be taxed at 6.625% like the rest of the check. On a $54 charge, that would add about $3.58. The bulletin covers tax only; it doesn’t say how or where a restaurant must tell diners about an automatic gratuity before they order.

Under Cruz’s video, some commenters quoted by the Daily Dot said servers earn little in base pay and depend on tips, and one argued that 20% should be the minimum. Another questioned why a tip should rise with the price of the food when the server makes the same trips. Many commenters raised servers’ low wages, Cruz told Fox.

Asked whether she would go back, Cruz didn’t sound likely to. “The food is really good, but I don’t think I would be back,” she said.

In other news, a woman said a bracelet artist added a 35% tip to her group’s $1,430 bill, and viewers told her to dispute it with her bank.

How we reported this

We read the interview and New Jersey’s published tax rules for restaurant gratuities.

Sources

0 comments