Politics

Rep. Tim Burchett says GTA VI is a guide to crime and blames parents, while Rep. Maxwell Frost plans to buy a PS5

The U.S. Capitol building with an inset portrait of Rep. Tim Burchett
Photo: Noclip, public domain. Inset: House Creative Services, public domain / Wikimedia Commons. / Public domain; public domain

Rep. Tim Burchett (R-Tenn.) told TMZ that GTA VI desensitizes kids and that parents who allow it are bad parents, while Rep. Maxwell Frost (D-Fla.) called the concern overblown and said he is buying a PS5.

Rep. Tim Burchett, a Tennessee Republican, says GTA VI desensitizes kids and that parents who let their children play it are bad parents. Florida Democrat Rep. Maxwell Frost says the criticism is overblown and that he is buying a PlayStation 5 to play it. TMZ asked both lawmakers about the game on Wednesday, Nov. 18, the day before its release.

Burchett compared the game to a how-to guide for stealing cars at gunpoint and shooting cops, and argued there is a direct connection between violent video games and real-world violence. He did not, however, call for Congress to act.

Frost said it is up to parents to decide what their kids play, and he said he was not allowed to play GTA growing up and settled for The Simpsons: Hit & Run. Now he says he has some serious catching up to do.

Burchett blames parents but does not want a law

Burchett joked that expecting lawmakers to legislate morality is laughable, given their own ethical track record. His criticism is aimed at parents rather than at a change in the law.

Frost pushed back on the link to violence, pointing out that other countries have the same video games without America’s level of gun violence.

QuestionRep. Burchett (R-Tenn.)Rep. Frost (D-Fla.)
Effect on kidsDesensitizes themConcern is overblown
Who decidesParents, and he calls those who allow it bad parentsParents
Role for CongressNot calling for congressional actionNot discussed in the report
Plans for launchNot statedBuying a PS5 to play it
Positions as stated on Nov. 18.
Official portrait of Rep. Maxwell Frost
Photo: U.S. House of Representatives, public domain / Wikimedia Commons

The Supreme Court has already ruled on a version of this fight

Congress would not be starting from scratch. In Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association, decided on June 27, 2011, the Supreme Court held that California’s restrictions on selling or renting violent video games to minors violated the First Amendment.

The Court found that psychological studies purporting to show a link between violent games and harm to children did not prove that such exposure causes those effects. It also noted that the video-game industry’s voluntary rating system already helps parents to a large extent, and that the California law was overinclusive because not every child it blocked had parents who objected to the games.

Parents are the same group both congressmen point to, whatever they think of the game. GTA VI went on sale on Nov. 19, and our unlock times by region show when each time zone could start playing.

How we reported this

We checked TMZ’s interview report and the Supreme Court’s published syllabus.

Sources

0 comments