Politics

Eleven Democrats missed the vote that killed the Hegseth impeachment, and the math shows it could have gone the other way

The U.S. Capitol with a circular inset portrait of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth in a file photo
Photo: Noclip / Wikimedia Commons. Inset: U.S. Department of Defense. File photos. / Public domain, cropped

The House voted 211 to 204 on Nov. 10 to refer Massie's impeachment resolution to committee. ABC says it would have failed 215 to 211 with every Democrat present.

The House voted 211 to 204 on Tuesday, Nov. 10, to refer Rep. Thomas Massie’s resolution to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee, which effectively kills it, per CBS News. The referral effectively shelved the resolution for the remainder of the 119th Congress, which ends on Jan. 3, 2027.

Eleven Democrats and seven Republicans did not vote. ABC News reports that if all 11 absent Democrats had voted no, the motion would have failed 215 to 211 and the impeachment resolution would have advanced.

Four days later, the missed vote is still a talking point for the incoming Democratic majority, and NPR published an analysis on Saturday calling it a failed first test and arguing it may have helped Hegseth. This article lays out the numbers and what comes next.

Would the vote really have gone the other way?

On paper, yes, if all existing votes stayed unchanged and the seven absent Republicans remained absent. Republicans hold a two-vote majority in the House, and ABC reports the vote was held open for 29 minutes although it was scheduled for 15. Even so, 11 Democrats were not in the chamber when it closed.

ScenarioTo refer (kill)Against
Actual vote211204
All 11 absent Democrats vote no211215
Only the six who arrived minutes later vote no211210
Source: ABC News tallies. Scenario rows are our reading of ABC’s math, not official counts.

ABC lists the absent Democrats as Julia Brownley, Lou Correa, Laura Gillen, Steven Horsford, Jonathan Jackson, Nancy Pelosi, Brittany Pettersen, Melanie Stansbury, Haley Stevens, Marilyn Strickland and Frederica Wilson. Only Correa announced his absence ahead of time, citing a medical procedure, and several others blamed a traffic incident and a police escort near the Capitol. ABC notes they knew about the 5:30 p.m. votes for at least 18 hours.

Pelosi’s spokesman told ABC she was in San Francisco for a veterans’ event and would have voted no. Votes later added to the Congressional Record do not change the result, ABC reports. Six of the Democrats reached the chamber for the next vote, and they alone would not have been enough, with the prospective tally at 211 to 210 per ABC.

So what do Democrats do now?

Massie, who is retiring in early January after losing his primary, said he will not bring another impeachment resolution. He said he plans to force a vote on a war powers resolution instead, to see whether Republicans who blamed the Iran war for their midterm losses will back it, per CBS.

Hegseth called the effort a “farce” and a “political spectacle,” and President Trump said it “miserably FAILED!” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said after the vote that it was “just the beginning.” Democrats could still force the issue when they take control of the House in January.

NPR cites a Reuters/Ipsos poll taken after the election in which 40 percent of respondents said investigating the Trump administration should be a priority in the first 100 days, versus eight in 10 who named the cost of living. Only 36 percent of independents said investigations should be a focus. That gap is the tightrope Jeffries has to walk.

Correction (November 16, 2026): Fact-checking fixes before publishing

How we reported this

We read CBS News and ABC News reports of the Nov. 10 vote and NPR's Nov. 14 analysis. We did not review the House roll call directly. The scenario rows in the table are our reading of ABC's math.

Sources

0 comments