World News

Auckland cafe worker’s thumbs-up emoji did not validly cut her guaranteed hours, authority rules in NZ$11,165.79 award

Barista making espresso at a cafe counter, with an inset of a cafe in Auckland
Photo: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0. Inset: Daderot, CC0 / Wikimedia Commons. / Main: File:Barista prepares espresso at coffee shop.jpg, Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0. Inset: File:Cafe - Auckland Botanic Gardens - Auckland, NZ - DSC08268.jpg, Daderot, CC0. Inline: File:Baristas serve espresso and cappuccino at a busy cafe.jpg, Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0.

New Zealand’s Employment Relations Authority ruled a cafe could not rely on a worker’s thumbs-up reply as a valid change to casual hours and ordered it to pay her NZ$11,165.79.

An Auckland cafe worker’s thumbs-up emoji was not a valid agreement to give up her guaranteed hours, New Zealand’s Employment Relations Authority has ruled, ordering the cafe’s operator to pay her NZ$11,165.79. The Authority’s written determination, dated Nov. 10, found Sharnika Manukonga was unjustifiably dismissed by Anthony and Emily Limited in April 2025.

Manukonga started front-of-house work on Feb. 24, 2025, after finishing school. Her employment agreement set normal hours of 25 to 35 a week over three to four days. She was gone from the roster seven weeks later.

The dispute turned on a text exchange from April 4, 2025. Manukonga told director Emily Ma she would be away for six days while house-sitting. Ma replied that she had moved her to a casual position, writing: “Casual means I can’t keep promises the hours.” When Manukonga asked whether she could go back to normal hours after that week, Ma wrote, “I’m not guarantee.” Manukonga answered with a thumbs-up.

Why one emoji could not rewrite the contract

The company relied on that reply as her agreement to switch from guaranteed hours to casual work. Authority member Sarah Blick noted the employment agreement did not require changes to be in writing, but found Ma’s explanation “unclear and insufficient in light of the significant change it represented to the employment.” Manukonga therefore stayed entitled to at least 25 hours a week.

On April 12, 2025, a new roster came out without her name. Asked why, Ma texted that she had decided to hire someone full time to replace her. When Manukonga asked if she was no longer needed, Ma replied, “Yes sorry,” according to the determination. Ma later told her no reason was required because she was still within a 90-day trial period.

That defence failed too. Manukonga signed her agreement on March 1, 2025, after working about three shifts, and the Authority cited Employment Court rulings requiring strict compliance with the trial rules, including that failing to sign before work starts is fatal to a trial clause. It also found the cafe never raised concerns with her, never warned her the job was at risk and never gave her a chance to respond. Blick called the dismissal “clearly unjustified.”

Baristas serving coffee at a busy cafe counter
Photo: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0 / Wikimedia Commons

How the NZ$11,165.79 adds up

AwardNZ$
Lost wages3,578.29
Compensation for humiliation and hurt7,000.00
One week’s notice pay587.50
Total11,165.79
Orders in Manukonga v Anthony and Emily Limited [2026] NZERA 834. The total is our sum of the three orders.

The three orders add up to exactly the NZ$11,165.79 reported by HCA Magazine and Stuff, so the coverage matches the document. The NZ$7,000 compensation payment makes up about 63% of the total.

At her rate of NZ$23.50 an hour, 25 hours is NZ$587.50 a week, which is where the notice figure comes from. Manukonga had claimed a shortfall of NZ$4,665.79 over 13 weeks. The Authority instead stopped the clock at June 30, 2025, and deducted the NZ$2,884.21 she earned in a new job up to that date. Its gross loss figure of NZ$6,462.50 equals exactly 11 weeks at NZ$587.50, although the determination describes the period as 10 weeks and says the notice week is handled separately.

She did not win everything. The Authority found the evidence insufficient for her separate grievance about how she said she was treated on shifts, including claims of being yelled at and jabbed with a finger, which the company denied. It also declined to impose penalties for breaches of good faith or the agreement.

A thumbs-up has carried legal weight elsewhere. In 2023, a Saskatchewan judge ruled that a flax seller’s thumbs-up reply to a photo of a flax contract was a valid acceptance and ordered damages of more than C$82,000, Canadian Lawyer reported. In that case the two sides had a history of agreeing contracts by short text replies such as “Looks good” and “Yup.”

Anthony and Emily Limited was ordered to pay within 14 days of the determination. Costs were reserved, and the parties were encouraged to settle them between themselves.

In other news, a $22,000 raise offer to stay out of management for two years has Reddit split.

How we reported this

We read the Employment Relations Authority determination and the news reports on it.

Sources

0 comments