Politics

Cassidy says he would replace RFK Jr. if he were president, after Kennedy said the Senate ‘no longer has any leverage’

Department of Health and Human Services headquarters entrance with an inset portrait of Sen. Bill Cassidy
Photo: G. Edward Johnson, Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons. File photo. / CC BY 4.0 / CC BY-SA 2.0

Sen. Bill Cassidy said on Face the Nation that he would choose someone else to run HHS, citing health costs, measles deaths and food policy.

Sen. Bill Cassidy, the Louisiana Republican who chairs the Senate health committee, said Sunday that he would pick a different health secretary if the decision were his. Asked about Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on CBS’s “Face the Nation,” Cassidy said, “If I were president, I would choose someone else,” according to CBS News.

He gave four reasons: higher health care costs, more measles deaths, the reported loss of the country’s measles elimination status and little progress on ultra-processed foods. Host Margaret Brennan opened the interview by citing KFF Health News reporting that the Pan American Health Organization had concluded the U.S. lost that status, although the organization had planned its public announcement for Nov. 17. Cassidy, a physician, said unvaccinated adults can pass the disease to babies too young for the shot, to pregnant women and to cancer patients.

Cassidy was answering a remark Kennedy made on Nov. 9: “The Senate no longer has any leverage over me.” Kennedy also named Stephen Miller, the president’s new chief of staff, as an ally. Cassidy called that an attempt to cover for failures and said there is no logic to the idea that Democratic control of the Senate will make Kennedy’s job easier. We did not find a response from Kennedy or HHS to Cassidy’s comments in the coverage we read.

How far has Cassidy moved since September?

Sixty-one days earlier, on Sept. 15, Cassidy spoke at a Semafor event and criticized the administration’s vaccine approach, saying he was angry that Kennedy had broken commitments made during his confirmation. He also declined to say whether he would back Heidi Overton, Trump’s pick to lead the FDA. On Sept. 16, Al Jazeera and Reuters reported his warnings about measles deaths in Pennsylvania. The state health department had confirmed four measles-associated deaths by then, including two newly announced on Sept. 15.

Sept. 15Cassidy says Kennedy broke commitments made at confirmation
Sept. 15Pennsylvania confirms two more measles deaths, four in 2026
Sept. 16Al Jazeera and Reuters report Cassidy’s warnings about measles deaths
Nov. 9Kennedy says the Senate has no leverage over him
Nov. 14KFF Health News reports PAHO concluded the U.S. lost measles elimination status; announcement planned Nov. 17
Nov. 15Cassidy says he would choose someone else

Kennedy’s confirmation last year hinged on Cassidy’s support, CBS notes, and Cassidy has said he backed it after receiving what he called “serious commitments.” He lost his Republican primary in May and is leaving the Senate.

What can the Senate still do?

The nearest test is the FDA nomination. Cassidy’s committee is scheduled to vote this week on Overton, and he said he still has questions and cannot say how it will go. He said he has spoken to four or five Republicans on the panel.

Brennan noted that Democratic Sens. Alsobrooks and Warnock have said Kennedy must resign or be fired, and that Dr. Annie Andrews, an incoming senator from South Carolina, ran on impeaching him. Brennan reminded Cassidy that he had previously said he saw no impeachable offense. He answered that impeachment can be brought over very little and that the decision is mainly the president’s. He said higher costs and the measles losses will weigh on Trump’s legacy.

How we reported this

We checked the interview transcript, the Pennsylvania Department of Health release, KFF Health News and earlier coverage.

Sources

0 comments