Erewhon is selling a $749 Thanksgiving dinner for 8 to 10 people, and it leaves out mac and cheese, green beans and cranberry sauce. TMZ reported on Nov. 18 that the upscale grocery chain is marketing the meal as its “Ultimate Organic Feast,” with those three sides sold separately.
The package includes a free-range cooked turkey, sourdough and roasted vegetable stuffing, rainbow carrots, Brussels sprouts, garlic mashed potatoes, turkey gravy and a deep-dish pumpkin pie. Some people online pointed out what was missing, since mac and cheese, cranberry sauce and green beans are traditional staples.
The sides can be bought as add-ons. The green beans almondine and the mac and cheese cost $55 each, and 16 ounces of cranberry sauce costs $29.
Adding all three sides brings the dinner to $888
The three extras add $139, bringing the listed total to $888 before any applicable taxes or fees. For ten people, that is $88.80 a head, compared with $74.90 for the base feast at the same headcount.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Ultimate Organic Feast (8 to 10 people) | $749 |
| Green beans almondine | $55 |
| Mac and cheese | $55 |
| Cranberry sauce, 16 oz | $29 |
| Feast plus all three sides | $888 |
| Farm Bureau classic dinner for 10, groceries | $58.63 |

That report compared the meal with the American Farm Bureau’s annual price survey. It gave the Farm Bureau figure as $58.63 per person, or just under $600 for ten, and concluded the Erewhon package is “not that much more” than a grocery store dinner.
The Farm Bureau’s release says something different. Its 41st annual survey puts the cost of a classic Thanksgiving dinner for ten at $58.63 in total, or about $5.86 per person. That is more than a 6% increase from 2025, and a 16-pound frozen turkey averages $23.68, or $1.48 per pound.
On those numbers, the $749 feast costs about 12.8 times the Farm Bureau’s total for ten, which is $749 against $58.63. The Farm Bureau’s expanded menu, which adds boneless ham, russet potatoes and frozen green beans, comes to $81.72.
The two are not a like-for-like comparison. The Farm Bureau prices groceries for a household to prepare, while Erewhon’s package includes a cooked turkey and sides. The Farm Bureau’s classic list also has no mac and cheese.
In other news, a New Jersey restaurant’s automatic gratuity for a party of five has drawn its own pricing complaints.