Politics

Pregnant U.S. citizen says ICE agents pepper-sprayed her and threw her down outside a California jail; video shows part

Modesto Arch with a circular inset of ICE officers
Photo: Carl Skaggs (public domain). Inset: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, file photo (public domain) / Wikimedia Commons. / Public domain

Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, 23, says ICE agents pepper-sprayed her and threw her to the ground outside the Stanislaus County Jail in Modesto on Nov. 15; video shows part of the encounter and DHS has not responded.

Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a 23-year-old woman who her attorney says is a U.S. citizen and who is 12 weeks pregnant, says federal immigration agents pepper-sprayed her, threw her to the ground and handcuffed her on Sunday outside the Stanislaus County Jail in Modesto, California. Her attorney, Patrick Kolasinski, shared video of the encounter that ABC News says appears to show parts of it.

The video was shot by her husband, Adolfo Talavera Alvarado. According to The Guardian’s description of the footage, she and an agent appear to bump into each other while she holds her phone, the agent grabs her and starts to handcuff her, another agent points what appears to be a pepper-spray canister toward her and her husband, and two agents then take her to the ground and cuff her on her stomach before one rolls her onto her side. Talavera can be heard saying, “She’s pregnant with child.” The sound repeatedly cuts out, and the footage does not show where the spray landed.

“They threw me to the ground, they maced me, then they handcuffed me,” Vargas Andrade told reporters on Sunday night. Agents told her she was accused of assaulting one of them, which she denies, saying the two bumped into each other. She was taken to an ICE field office in Stockton and held for several hours, according to her attorney. Her family says her sister called an ambulance that took her to a hospital. Kolasinski told ABC News she had not been charged. ABC reported that doctors found the baby unharmed after a hospital evaluation.

File photo of ICE enforcement officers in tactical vests standing together
File photo: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (public domain) / Wikimedia Commons

What the video shows and what is disputed

Vargas Andrade said she belongs to a group of local residents who monitor immigration enforcement in the Central Valley and went to the jail parking lot after agents were spotted there. The Guardian reports that agents moved to arrest a man who appeared to have just been released from the jail, while Kolasinski says agents blocked her sister-in-law’s vehicle and a man in it was detained. The Guardian says the man arrested has not been identified, and the sources do not say whether he is the same man Kolasinski describes.

MomentIn the footageWhat is claimed
Pepper sprayAn agent points a canister; the spray is partly capturedShe says she was “burning”; her husband says he and his sister were sprayed too
TakedownTwo agents bring her down; she is cuffed facedown, then rolled onto her sideShe says she hit her stomach area
Why agents grabbed herNot clear; the audio cuts outAgents accused her of assaulting one; she denies it
PregnancyHer husband says she is pregnant before the takedownShe says an ultrasound found no concerns
Based on descriptions of the video and statements reported by The Guardian, ABC News, CBS Sacramento and Newsweek.

ABC News sought DHS comment

Spokespeople for the Department of Homeland Security had not responded to CBS Sacramento or The Guardian by Monday night, ABC News said it had reached out to DHS, and the Justice Department declined to comment to The Guardian. A spokesperson for the Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Office, which runs the jail, said deputies were not involved in the arrest.

The encounter came amid reports of increased ICE activity in California’s Central Valley. The Guardian also notes that DHS and the Justice Department have repeatedly accused anti-ICE protesters of assaulting agents, though many of those prosecutions in California have fallen apart in federal court, and Newsweek adds that a ProPublica investigation published in October identified more than 500 U.S. citizens detained by immigration agents since President Donald Trump returned to office.

Vargas Andrade returned to the parking lot with her husband and attorney on Monday to call for accountability, CBS Sacramento reports. At a news conference on Sunday night she had said: “We’re not going to stop helping the community even though this happened. We want our immigrants to feel safe here.”

How we reported this

We read the news reports and what they say the video shows.

Sources

0 comments