Politics

Twelve GOP-led states appeal ruling blocking the Postal Service mail ballot rule, but the Justice Department won’t

An official county ballot drop box with an American flag design on a sidewalk in a file photo
Photo: Paul Sableman / Wikimedia Commons. File photo. / CC BY 2.0, cropped

The order covers every federal election, including 2028, and the Justice Department has confirmed it is not appealing.

Twelve Republican-led states have started an appeal of a federal judge’s order that blocks a Postal Service rule on mail ballots. The notice was filed on Thursday, the last day to do it, according to NPR.

Here is the awkward part: the Trump administration, whose executive order led to the rule, says it will not appeal the same ruling. A Justice Department filing confirmed that, so the states are carrying the case on their own.

The stakes reach past this year’s midterms, which just ended. The injunction covers every federal election, including the 2028 presidential race, so whoever wins this appeal decides how mail ballots can be handled the next time the White House is on the ballot.

Wait, what is this rule actually?

The Postal Service released the rule in late August in response to an executive order from President Trump. It would require states to hand over lists of voters’ names and addresses in order to have their mail ballots delivered through the Postal Service, according to NPR.

Election officials were alarmed about last-minute changes affecting tens of millions of people who regularly vote by mail, including voters with disabilities and people in places without polling sites. A whistleblower report also claimed the online system officials would have had to use had not been properly tested and could have left many eligible voters without ballots in time, or at all.

U.S. District Judge Carl Nichols, a Trump nominee in Washington, issued a preliminary injunction in September. He found that the Postal Service likely lacks the legal authority to impose the requirement on states. The attorneys general of Alabama, Florida, Indiana, Kansas, Louisiana, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota and Texas are now challenging that order.

Two judges, two orders, and one open question

Nichols (Washington)Talwani (Boston)
What it blocksThe Postal Service from implementing its planThe Postal Service from working on its revised rule
Which electionsAll federal elections, including 2028This year’s midterms only
Where it standsTwelve states are appealing; the Justice Department is notThe Supreme Court declined to pause it in September; Alito and Thomas dissented
Source: NPR.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh agreed with that decision but wrote that election officials lacked time to implement the rule this year, and that there is a fair prospect the final rule falls within the Postal Service’s authority. That leaves the question open for a later fight, and the states’ appeal is one way to get it back in front of judges.

It is also unclear how long every state will stay in the case. NPR notes that Democratic candidates are set to take over the attorney general offices in Texas and Kansas in January after Democrats won up and down the ballot in the midterms.

How we reported this

This report relies on NPR's account of the appeal notice and the Justice Department filing. We have not reviewed the court documents directly and will update the article if they say more.

Sources

0 comments